Skip to content
Racecard Stats Subscribe

4 min read ·

Secretariat’s Times Compared to Other Horses: What the Gaps Mean

Compare Secretariat’s Triple Crown times with Monarchos, Swiss Skydiver, American Pharoah and other champions—and learn what raw times can tell you.

Share X in f
Fiona Drummond · 4 min read

Secretariat’s 1973 Kentucky Derby time was 0.57 seconds quicker than Monarchos’s 2001 winning time. His official Preakness time was 0.28 seconds quicker than Swiss Skydiver’s in 2020. At the Belmont, his 2:24.00 was 2.65 seconds quicker than American Pharoah’s 2015 performance. Those are differences between recorded winning times—not margins from horses racing against one another. (Derby comparison, Preakness comparison, Belmont comparison)

The useful comparison starts with the same race, course and distance. Even then, the clock records a performance under particular conditions, not a horse’s fixed level of ability.

Secretariat against other winning performances

A winning time is the elapsed time recorded for the winner over the timed race distance. Here, 1:59.40 means one minute and 59.40 seconds, or 119.40 seconds. Historical fifths have been converted to decimals: 2:26 4/5 becomes 2:26.80. That makes subtraction easier without implying that older clocks measured to hundredths.

Race and distance Secretariat, 1973 Comparison horse and year Other winning time Longer than Secretariat’s time
Kentucky Derby, Churchill Downs, 1¼ miles 1:59.40 Monarchos, 2001 1:59.97 0.57 sec
Preakness, Pimlico, 1³⁄₁₆ miles 1:53.00 Swiss Skydiver, 2020 1:53.28 0.28 sec
Belmont Stakes, Belmont Park, 1½ miles 2:24.00 Easy Goer, 1989; A.P. Indy, 1992 2:26.00 each 2.00 sec
Belmont Stakes, Belmont Park, 1½ miles 2:24.00 American Pharoah, 2015 2:26.65 2.65 sec
Belmont Stakes, Belmont Park, 1½ miles 2:24.00 Affirmed, 1978 2:26.80 2.80 sec
Belmont Stakes, Belmont Park, 1½ miles 2:24.00 Justify, 2018 2:28.18 4.18 sec

Sources: Associated Press on Monarchos, 2020 Preakness report, and NYRA’s Belmont winners table. Gaps are calculated by subtraction. These are selected comparisons, not a complete fastest-times ranking.

The Belmont gap is especially striking. Converting both times to seconds gives 146.65 − 144.00 = 2.65 seconds for American Pharoah versus Secretariat. That establishes which recorded performance took less time. It does not establish that Secretariat would beat American Pharoah by a particular number of lengths in a hypothetical race.

NYRA lists all the Belmont horses above at 126 lb. Equal carried weight removes one obvious difference, but it does not make their track conditions or pace identical. (NYRA records)

For a broader list, see the fastest Belmont Stakes times at 1½ miles.

Two comparisons that need extra care

Secretariat’s Preakness time was revised

Use 1:53.00, not 1:54.40, when comparing the official result. On June 19, 2012, the Maryland Racing Commission voted unanimously to revise Secretariat’s time after hearing testimony and evidence about the 1973 timing. Older publications can therefore show a different figure. (Commission meeting minutes)

A stakes record also differs from a track record. Farma Way ran the same 1³⁄₁₆-mile trip at Pimlico in 1:52.40 in the 1991 Pimlico Special—0.60 seconds quicker than Secretariat’s Preakness time, but in a different race. Secretariat’s Preakness achievement should not be described as proof that no horse ran that course and distance faster. (BloodHorse)

Man o’ War’s Belmont covered a shorter distance

NYRA records Man o’ War’s 1920 Belmont winning time as 2:14 1/5, or 2:14.20. It looks quicker than Secretariat’s 2:24.00 until you check the trip: the Belmont was 1⅜ miles in 1920, rather than Secretariat’s 1½ miles. One furlong less makes direct subtraction misleading. (Winning time, historical distances)

What this teaches you about racecard times

A raw time and a speed figure are different fields. A figure-maker attempts to make performances comparable rather than simply rewarding the shortest elapsed time. Andrew Beyer explains that his calculations compare times across distances and tracks, account for the track’s speed, and sometimes require judgment when pace or changing conditions distort the clock. He also distinguishes a speed figure from an all-encompassing ability rating. (DRF’s Beyer methodology Q&A)

When comparing previous runs on a racecard:

  • Match the distance and surface first. A shorter race will usually produce a shorter time without demonstrating superior ability.
  • Check the course and going or track condition. The same trip does not guarantee equally demanding conditions.
  • Check timing arrangements where available. In U.S. racing, the run-up is the distance from the starting gate to the point where timing begins. It can affect recorded times, so a race time is not necessarily a gate-to-finish time. (Beyer on run-ups)
  • Read carried weight, pace and race circumstances alongside the clock. They help explain what a horse achieved and whether the performance is relevant to today’s race.
  • Identify the metric. Seconds, speed figures and ability ratings answer different questions; don’t treat them as interchangeable.

The speed-figure provider comparison explains those distinctions in more detail. Secretariat’s times are exceptional historical performances; using them well means preserving the race conditions that give the numbers their meaning.